Choosing between Penhaligon's and The Different Company in the gift sets category can be tricky. Both brands offer niche fragrance selections, but with different styles and positioning.
This guide provides a clear, data-driven comparison: we look at price ranges, available sizes, best sellers, and each brand’s strengths to help you decide which gift set suits your needs or those of someone you want to surprise.
The products we talk about
Brand positioning and philosophy
Penhaligon's is a historic English brand, known for refined fragrances and attention to detail in its gift boxes, often designed as luxury presents. The Different Company stands out for a more contemporary, minimalist approach, focusing on versatility and portability, especially in travel sets.
- Penhaligon's: tradition, elegance, carefully crafted packaging.
- The Different Company: modernity, practicality, unisex and travel sets.
Price ranges and available sizes
Penhaligon's gift sets cover a wide price range: from €60.11 for miniature sets (like "Penhaligon's Portraits Scent Library Set and Gift Boxes") up to €557.17 for the most exclusive boxes (e.g., "Penhaligon's Halfeti Holiday Set 2025 Eau de Parfum"). Most sets fall between €78 and €332.
The Different Company sets start at around €100.59 ("Majaina Sin Unisex 4× 7.5 ml — Set") and go up to €276.00 ("Santo Incenso, Sillage Sacré Unisex 4× 7.5 ml — Travel Kit"), with most products priced between €125 and €207.
- Penhaligon's also offers multi-size sets and collector’s boxes.
- The Different Company focuses on travel sizes (4×7.5 ml) and unisex kits.
Best sellers and strengths
Among Penhaligon's best sellers are the "Penhaligon's Bestseller Scent Library Discovery Set Eau de Parfum" (€78.20) and the "Penhaligon's Festive Mini Set Men 2025 — Gift Set" (€107.52). These sets provide a broad experience of the house’s fragrances, ideal for those wanting to explore various scents.
The Different Company offers sets like "Al Sahra Unisex 4× 7.5 ml — Travel Set" (€207.37) and "After Midnight Unisex 4× 7.5 ml — Travel Kit" (€150.81), designed for those seeking convenience and the ability to carry multiple fragrances in a compact format.
- Penhaligon's: wide range of sizes, elegant gift packaging, options for men and women.
- The Different Company: unisex sets, travel sizes, focus on portability.
Who should choose Penhaligon's, who The Different Company
If you want a striking gift with elegant packaging and a selection of iconic fragrances, Penhaligon's is the better choice. Their sets are perfect for those who appreciate tradition and want to impress with a premium box.
The Different Company is aimed at those who prefer practicality, want to try multiple scents in travel size, or are looking for a versatile unisex gift. It’s also great for frequent travelers who want to carry several fragrances without bulk.
Summary comparison
| Aspect | Penhaligon's | The Different Company |
|---|---|---|
| Price range | From €60.11 to €557.17 | From €100.59 to €276.00 |
| Best sellers | Bestseller Scent Library Discovery Set, Festive Mini Set Men 2025 | Al Sahra Travel Set, After Midnight Travel Kit |
| Sizes | Miniatures, multi-size, deluxe boxes | 4×7.5 ml travel sets, unisex kits |
| Specialties | Elegant gift packaging, wide men/women selection | Portability, unisex sets, contemporary fragrances |
| Who it’s for | Those seeking an elegant, traditional gift | Those wanting practicality, variety, and travel sizes |
| Availability on Papique | 16 gift sets | 12 gift sets |
| Discounts | Some sets discounted, e.g. Dainty Tartlets Miniature Set Women | Some sets discounted, e.g. Al Sahra Unisex Travel Set |
Frequently asked questions
What is the most affordable Penhaligon's gift set?
The most affordable is the "Penhaligon's Portraits Scent Library Set and Gift Boxes" at €60.11, when available.
Does The Different Company offer travel sets?
Yes, most of The Different Company's sets are 4×7.5 ml travel sets, ideal for travelers.
Does Penhaligon's have sets for both men and women?
Yes, there are sets specifically for men and women, as well as mixed boxes and discovery sets.
What is the main difference between the two brands’ gift sets?
Penhaligon's focuses on elegance and tradition, while The Different Company emphasizes practicality and unisex formats.
Are there discounts available on these gift sets?
Yes, on Papique some sets from both brands are discounted, and you can use the newsletter code for an extra 4% off.
Shipping to over 60 countries from Italy: outside the EU duties and taxes are included in the price (DDP), no surprises at delivery. Returns within 14 days of delivery. Newsletter discount code: 4RARE. Prices and availability updated on 2026-10-16.