If you're looking for quality hair products, you've probably come across the Milk Shake and David Mallett brands. Both are available on Papique and offer specific solutions for different needs, but they differ significantly in positioning, pricing, and range.
This guide provides an honest comparison between Milk Shake and David Mallett: we analyze real price ranges, best-selling products, sizes, and strengths. This way, you can choose the brand that suits you best, based on your needs and budget.
The products we talk about
Positioning and product range
Milk Shake offers a wide range of hair products: on Papique you'll find 66 items ranging from shampoos, conditioners, and masks to specific treatments like the K-Respect Smoothing Treatment. The brand targets those looking for professional yet affordable solutions, with products for coloring, color maintenance, nourishment, and styling.
- Coloring and color maintenance: Milk Shake Pink Lemonade Pink Hair Coloring Conditioner 1000 ml (€49,24), Milk Shake Color Maintenance Conditioner 300 ml (€17,27).
- Shampoos and treatments: Milk Shake Purifying Blend Anti-Dandruff Purifying Shampoo 1000 ml (€37,51), Milk Shake Integrity Hair Mask 500 ml (€40,48).
- Styling: Milk Shake Lifestyling Firming Paste 90 ml (€52,03).
David Mallett, on the other hand, positions itself as a niche luxury brand, with a more curated collection (16 products on Papique) focused on masks, shampoos, conditioners, and styling products. The formulas cater to those seeking refined ingredients and an exclusive experience.
- Nourishing masks: David Mallett Mask N1 180 ml (€113,39), Mask N3 180 ml (€92,83).
- Shampoos: David Mallett Shampoo N3 250 ml (€126,50), Shampoo N2 250 ml (€74,29).
- Styling and serums: David Mallett Styling Cream (€82,11), Volumizing Powder (€74,29), Hair and Scalp Rescue Elixir (€244,37).
Real price ranges and sizes
The price difference between the two brands is significant. Milk Shake offers products priced from around €17 (Color Maintenance Conditioner 300 ml) up to €471.50 (K-Respect Smoothing Treatment 250 ml), but most items fall between €35 and €60 for large 1000 ml sizes.
- Milk Shake shampoos and conditioners 1000 ml: between €35.42 and €55.48.
- Milk Shake Hair Mask 500 ml: €40.48.
David Mallett starts at about €74 (Shampoo N2 250 ml, Volumizing Powder) up to €244.37 (Hair and Scalp Rescue Elixir), with smaller sizes (shampoos and masks from 180-250 ml). The average price for shampoos and masks ranges from €74 to €126.
- David Mallett shampoos 250 ml: from €74.29 to €126.50.
- David Mallett hair masks 180 ml: from €92.83 to €113.39.
Strengths and specialties of each brand
Milk Shake stands out for its variety of solutions, large sizes, and presence of products specifically for coloring and color maintenance. It's ideal if you want good value for quantity and need products for frequent use or family.
- Specialties: treatments for colored hair, anti-dandruff, volumizing, and smoothing.
- Sizes: many products in 1000 ml, perfect for those wanting to save in the long run.
David Mallett focuses on refined formulas, selected ingredients, and a premium positioning. The products are designed for those seeking high performance and a simple yet sophisticated routine.
- Specialties: nourishing masks, purifying shampoos, repair serums and elixirs.
- Sizes: compact products (180-250 ml), ideal for those wanting to try high-end treatments or indulge in an exclusive pampering.
Who is Milk Shake best for and who is David Mallett for?
Choose Milk Shake if you want a wide selection of products, large sizes, and affordable prices. It suits those with daily routine needs, families, or anyone wanting to maintain color without spending too much.
David Mallett is the right choice if you seek niche products, want to invest in premium treatments, and prefer more exclusive and targeted formulas. Ideal for demanding hair or those wanting a luxury routine.
Summary comparison
| Aspect | Milk Shake | David Mallett |
|---|---|---|
| Price range | €17.27 - €471.50 (most between €35 and €60) | €74.29 - €244.37 (shampoos/masks €74-126) |
| Best-selling products | Pink Lemonade Coloring Conditioner, Purifying Blend Shampoo, Integrity Mask | Mask N1, Shampoo N3, Hair Rescue Elixir |
| Available sizes | 300 ml, 500 ml, 1000 ml | 180 ml, 250 ml |
| Specialties | Coloring, color maintenance, anti-dandruff, smoothing | Nourishing masks, purifying shampoos, repair elixirs |
| Who it's for | Frequent use, families, those seeking quantity/value | Those wanting luxury products and selected formulas |
| Number of products available | 66 | 16 |
| Availability of large sizes | Yes (up to 1000 ml) | No (max 250 ml) |
Explore all Milk Shake and David Mallett hair products · Capelli Milk Shake (66)
Explore all Milk Shake and David Mallett hair products · Capelli David Mallett (16)
Frequently asked questions
Is Milk Shake more affordable than David Mallett?
Yes, most Milk Shake products cost less than David Mallett's, especially in larger sizes.
What are Milk Shake's most popular products?
Among the most popular are Pink Lemonade Coloring Conditioner, Purifying Blend Shampoo, and Integrity Hair Mask.
Does David Mallett offer products for colored hair?
David Mallett's range focuses on nourishing masks, shampoos, and repair treatments, not on coloring.
What sizes do David Mallett products come in?
Main sizes are 180 ml for masks and 250 ml for shampoos and conditioners.
Who is Milk Shake suitable for?
Milk Shake suits those looking for accessible professional solutions, large sizes, and a wide range for every need.
Shipping to over 60 countries from Italy: outside the EU duties and taxes are included in the price (DDP), no surprises at delivery. Returns within 14 days of delivery. Newsletter discount code: 4RARE. Prices and availability updated on 2026-10-24.